Mets Hit Record Luxury Tax Bill: Baseball's Unprecedented Tax Penalties

In a historic turn of events, the New York Mets are set to pay an extraordinary luxury tax of almost $101 million, marking a record in Major League Baseball. The Mets, owned by Steve Cohen, concluded the 2023 season with a tax payroll of $374.7 million, eclipsing the previous high set by the 2015 Los Angeles Dodgers. Despite a significant summer selloff, shedding players like Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander, the Mets' tax bill soared to $100,781,932 after a lackluster fourth-place finish in the NL East.

It is important to note that this so-called tax is imposed by Major League Baseball on teams whose owners opt to exceed a pre-determined payroll threshold. It is not a federal tax imposed by the IRS. As defined on theleague's website, "Each year, clubs that exceed a predetermined payroll threshold are subject to a Competitive Balance Tax — commonly referred to as a 'luxury tax.'”

"Those who carry payrolls above that threshold are taxed on each dollar above the threshold, with the tax rate increasing based on the number of consecutive years a club has exceeded the threshold."

Per an Associated Press report, a tax credit of $2,126,471 mitigated the Mets' final bill under a provision in the latest collective bargaining agreement. However, the club’s two-year tax total stands at a staggering $131.6 million. Other notable teams facing tax penalties include the San Diego Padres ($39.7 million), the New York Yankees ($32.4 million), the Los Angeles Dodgers ($19.4 million), the Philadelphia Phillies ($6.98 million), the Toronto Blue Jays ($5.5 million), the Atlanta Braves ($3.2 million), and the 2023 World Series champion Texas Rangers ($1.8 million).

The Yankees and Mets were the sole franchises to surpass the $293 million threshold, implemented in the 2022 labor contract, known as the Cohen Tax, designed to curb Steve Cohen's spending. According to the AP, this year's collective tax reached a whopping $209.8 million, more than double the prior record of $78.5 million for 2022. Total spending on luxury tax payrolls soared to an unprecedented $5.79 billion, a 12.2% increase from the previous year. As the Yankees' cumulative tax payments since 2003 near $390 million, it solidifies their status as the highest-taxed team in MLB history.

The tax landscape for 2024 brings a new initial threshold of $237 million, with teams like the Mets, Yankees, Dodgers, Padres, and Phillies facing escalating tax rates if they surpass designated thresholds. As baseball grapples with unparalleled financial dynamics, the Mets' colossal tax bill serves as a testament to the evolving fiscal challenges within the sport.

As the Mets grapple with the aftermath of a record-setting luxury tax bill, the beginning of 2024 heralds a familiar tune for the Queens-based team. The New York Post notes that with spring training looming in six weeks, the Mets, under the helm of new president of baseball operations David Stearns, find themselves amid an uneventful start to free agency. Despite Luis Severino's one-year, $13 million deal, the rotation and other key positions remain glaringly understaffed.

Amid financial constraints after the tax blow, the Mets face challenges in acquiring marquee names, leaving openings in the rotation, bullpen, third base, and the outfield. The failed pursuit of Yoshinobu Yamamoto has prompted exploration of alternatives, with Shota Imanaga and other free agents on their radar. With a hesitant approach to long-term deals, the Mets are strategically navigating the market while resetting in 2024.

On the pitching front, options like Blake Snell and Jordan Montgomery might be out of reach, directing attention toward cost-effective choices like Imanaga and the returning Hyun-jin Ryu. Ryu's recent performance for Toronto presents a viable one-year deal, aligning with the Mets' cautious spending strategy post-Yamamoto. In the lineup, potential acquisitions include former Yankee Gio Urshela and the versatile Justin Turner, who could add depth and flexibility to key positions.

Carmen Mandato / Getty Images Sport via Getty Images

 As the Mets face a pivotal turn point in reshaping their roster, financial considerations and strategic moves on and off the field will define their trajectory into the upcoming season.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
I consent to receive SMS messages

Standing Up for People Like You

Get to Know Us

Welcome to Books, Taxes & More, located in Atlanta's southwestern suburb, Stone Mountain, GA. We proudly specialize in providing top-tier IRS and state tax authority representation, with additional services in tax preparation and bookkeeping. Our tax representation services are designed for clients who recognize they have a tax problem and want to resolve it urgently.

We also offer comprehensive tax preparation services, especially for those with complex returns, and bookkeeping as a supplementary service.

IRS and State Tax Authority Representation

If you've received a letter from the IRS or the state department of revenue, you need an expert who can help you navigate these challenges swiftly and effectively. We work with taxpayers who have the resources to invest in high-quality representation, and a collaborative mindset. We pride ourselves on our expertise and commitment to resolving your tax issues efficiently. With over a decade of experience, we know how to protect taxpayers from the IRS and state authorities, ensuring your financial well-being.

Why Choose Us?

  • Expertise and Experience: With over ten years in the industry and credentials as a Certified Tax Resolution Consultant, our founder, Steve Perry, brings a wealth of knowledge to each client engagement. Steve is also a member of the National Association of Enrolled Agents (NAEA) and the Tax Rep Network.

  • Passion for Advocacy: Our team is passionate about defending our clients against the IRS and resolving tax debt issues. We believe in standing up against bullies and helping you achieve financial freedom.

  • Specialized Knowledge: Our continuous education, including extensive studies in cryptocurrency and blockchain, enables us to support crypto traders and other clients with unique financial situations.

  • Community Involvement: As an active member of Rotary Club International and other local volunteer efforts, Steve is dedicated to making a positive impact both professionally and personally.

Make your business more profitable today.

Call us at (678) 717-9818 for a consultation.

Contact Us Now